What works for coughs?

Written by Dr. Kate McCann
15th November 2022

“I was always under the impression that under 6’s should not be giving cough bottles as they find it trickier to cough up their mucus in the first place so shouldn’t be further discouraged but I have recently learned that bronchio stop markets itself for over 1s???!!!! ( is that not madness?!)Just with the prominence of RSV and croup and other nasty respiratory virus could I ask you to possibly post some information regarding this?”

Cough bottles. Great topic.

Let’s back right up to prevention to start.  The best treatment for cough is prevention: wash hands, teach cough etiquette, keep sick children home from school/creche/playground, make sure childhood vaccinations are up-to-date, and, as always,  #flushot is #yourbestshot this winter. What doesn’t work to prevent viral coughs and colds? Excess Vitamin C, Vitamin D (both have a role in supporting healthy immune system but extra doesn’t “boost your immunity” – have a look back on recent deeper dive on staying healthy this winter) Neither do pre/probiotics, homeopathy, salt caves, or herbal tonics.

If concerned about a cough, touch base with your GP. Especially if your child has asthma. Uncontrolled or new asthma in children can present as a cough or a cough worse at night.  It doesn’t always have to have a wheeze (click on link for look back on previous asthma mythbusting)

Okay, so onto the viral cough. You’re right. No cough bottles. 2 reasons: 1) They are useless, for the most part. 2) Some are not safe for young children.

The common popular cough bottles marketed to children in Ireland right now are herbal prepararations containing marshmallow root, honey, and/or thyme. They have applied for use as a traditional product: it means they didn’t have to show that it actually works in a trial. Yes, that is legal in Ireland for certain classifications of supplements and remedies to be sold making claims that they haven’t had to prove (if you check the product information for the section where drugs have to list the pharmacokinetics/pharmacodynamics, you will find it just cites a law that says they don’t have to do that.).

What else is commonly cited in mammy WhatsApp groups that isn’t a good idea?  Antihistamines for viral cough in young children – unless specifically recommended by your GP.  What doesn’t work?  Any variety of cut up vegetables stuck in corners of the room/radiators/socks**.

Cough bottles marketed for adults or some purchased/imported from abroad may contain: dextromethorphan, codeine, or pseudoephedrine. None recommended for children under 12 for over-the-counter use for viral cough (and some of those should be used with caution in adults as well.).

Okay, that’s all the bad news. So, what works?

1. Honey. Yes, a spoonful of honey (for children over age of 12 months). Would it surprise you to know that there has been clinical trials?  And it really worked (better than cough bottles).  Any honey will do – doesn’t need to be local. Though local is, of course, tastier, carbon-friendly, and #supportlocal

2. Warm drinks

3. Humidified air: using a warm steam or cool mist vaporiser may help

4.  If using products to ease congestions such as Calpol plug-ins or Vicks – always follow the directions.  For what it’s worth, Vicks has a baby and adult preparation.  It works by being inhaled – so does far more good on the chest than on feet under socks under blankets**.

For what it’s worth, infectious disease experts to predict a particularly bad winter for viral respiratory illnesses which will include RSV, parainfluenzae, flu as well as covid. It will help for us all to do our part, follow public health advice,  and practice good hygiene and cough etiquette.

**Did you know?  Some of the practices such as cutting up onions and placing in room or focusing on the feet for chest conditions from practices from 4 -5 centuries ago that originated as ways to ward off Plague before the world understood germs. They have persisted in folk practice. 

Comments

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Healthy Back to School: Immune-boosting and “Crechitis”

 All this week is #HealthyBackToSchool series.   It is only a matter of days before the online parent groups are full of despair at suddenly finding their young child out of school – just days after starting – with illnesses.  “Is there something going around?”  This...

Hot Lunch Controversy? Oh, let’s weight in!

My children are, again, going to get the school hot lunch programme this year. Really? Yes. Here's why: 1. Facts Not Fears: Much of the fear-mongering around the content of the lunch programme are by the same supermarket influencers and their tired, attention-seeking...

Healthy Back Loo School

An bhfuil cead agam dul go dtí an leithreas? If your child - or teen - is back to school, you've probably asked them how they like their new teacher or what day PE is.  But -- have you asked them about the toilets? Yes, it's a thing.  Look, if it's not a thing for...

Related Posts

Lifestyle Medicine Consultations

Get Started Today